The declining commercial tax base and fluctuating property values due to the work-from-home trend pose significant challenges for assessment departments. Leaders must navigate these complex realities, potentially requiring a mix of strategic vision, financial acumen, and industry-specific knowledge to effectively address the resulting vacancies and property value shifts.
The traditional
practice in major assessment jurisdictions of promoting chief assessors from
within or hiring from competitors is no longer effective. These roles now
demand exceptional leadership and vision, qualities that technical assessing
skills cannot solely measure. It's time for large municipalities, especially
assessing agencies, to adopt a new approach. Drawing inspiration from corporate
America, they should select top-line leaders based on broader skills and
experiences.
The top-school
MBAs become successful CEOs of major corporations because they are specially
trained to be professional managers and leaders irrespective of the type of
business or industry. Now that corporate CEOs are hired worldwide, the
increased competition would force many top-school MBAs with rewarding
backgrounds in leading banks, national real estate brokerages, leading real
estate valuation, research and rating houses, management consulting with
significant exposure to the real estate industry, etc., to consider careers in
state and local governments. Therefore, those jobs, especially the ones from
the larger jurisdictions, should also be advertised in major job sites,
national newspapers, and WSJ, highlighting the challenge and the resulting
reward. Even if a small percentage of those MBAs are amenable, it will be a
win-win situation for the taxpayers.
The technical
interview to hire a Chief Assessor must not be internalized. It promotes more
politics and favoritism; it should be conducted by a select committee
comprising local CEOs, renowned professors, and other industry leaders.
It's important to
note that some jurisdictions may have statutory qualification requirements for
the Chief Assessor. However, due to dire straits of property tax revenue in
many jurisdictions, property assessing is expected to undergo a complete
transformation, leading to eliminating industry qualification requirements of
old standing. Meanwhile, a handful of visionary jurisdictions without such
statutory qualification requirements must take the quantum leap toward hiring
top-school MBAs to lead those agencies, disrupting the industry's age-old
hiring tradition.
Critical Analysis
There is no denying that hiring top-school MBAs with backgrounds in the
industry as Chief Assessors of large metropolitan assessment agencies is a
potentially disruptive approach to addressing the challenges posed by the
declining commercial tax base. Here are some critical analysis points to
consider:
1. Leadership and
Vision: It is critically important to hire visionary leaders with solid business understanding, especially given the changing work landscape and economic uncertainties. Chief Assessors must anticipate trends, adapt to changes,
and find innovative solutions to maintain tax revenue streams. MBAs with diverse
real estate experiences could bring fresh perspectives and strategic thinking
to the role.
2. Broader Skill Set: In today's complex environment, the need for a
broader skill set, including managerial and leadership experience, is urgent.
Traditional assessors may excel in technical assessing skills, but leadership,
communication, and strategic decision-making are equally crucial. Hiring
individuals with these skills could enhance the ability of assessment agencies
to navigate challenges effectively.
3. Recruitment Strategy: Advertising Chief Assessor positions on major job
sites and national newspapers will strategically attract top-school MBAs,
potentially drawing in candidates with the desired skill set and experience and
expanding the talent pool beyond traditional hires. However, ensuring that the
recruitment process is transparent and unbiased is essential to avoid
allegations of favoritism.
4. Industry Qualification
Requirements:
While some jurisdictions may have statutory qualification requirements for
Chief Assessors, these requirements could be re-evaluated in the face of
changing circumstances and the need for transformation. This re-evaluation
could shift toward prioritizing leadership and managerial competencies
over traditional industry qualifications, opening up new possibilities and
potential benefits for assessment agencies.
5. Implementation
Challenges:
Transitioning from traditional hiring practices to a new model involving
top-school MBAs with industry backgrounds may face resistance from (within) the
organization and the industry. Ensuring buy-in from stakeholders, providing
adequate training and support for new hires, and managing potential cultural
clashes will be critical for successful implementation.
6. Evaluation
Metrics:
Establishing clear performance metrics and benchmarks to assess the
effectiveness of this new approach would be essential. Monitoring the impact of
hiring top-school MBAs on revenue generation, operational efficiency, and
stakeholder satisfaction would determine the initiative's
success.
Redefining Domain Knowledge
Domain knowledge in the context of property assessments must
evolve to cover a broader spectrum beyond technical assessment knowledge. As
property assessments navigate the changing landscape influenced by remote work
trends, economic uncertainties, and technological advancements, Chief Assessors
must possess a more diverse skill set to lead assessment departments in major
metropolitans effectively. This expanded domain knowledge includes:
1. Understanding of New Revenue
Sources:
With the decline in commercial tax bases due to remote work trends, Chief
Assessors must have a deep understanding of alternative sources of revenue
generation, which may involve exploring innovative taxation models, leveraging
public-private partnerships, or identifying new revenue streams to compensate
for lost tax revenue.
2. Proficiency in Advanced Technology: Introducing advanced AI technology in property assessments can
enhance efficiency, accuracy, and cost-effectiveness. Chief Assessors must be
familiar with the latest technological tools and trends in the industry to
optimize assessment processes, automate repetitive tasks, and improve data
analysis and valuation modeling.
3. Knowledge of Regulatory
Environment:
Property assessments are subject to a complex regulatory environment that is
constantly evolving. Chief Assessors must stay updated on legislative changes,
compliance requirements, and industry standards to ensure that assessment
practices align with legal and ethical guidelines.
4. Financial Acumen: Understanding financial
principles, budget management, and
fiscal planning is crucial for Chief Assessors to make informed decisions,
allocate resources effectively, and optimize revenue generation strategies.
5. Stakeholder Management: Building relationships with various stakeholders, including
government officials, property owners, community members, and industry experts,
is essential for Chief Assessors to communicate assessment policies
effectively, address concerns, and foster collaboration.
Case
Study
Hiring a new CEO at Starbucks from Chipotle is a compelling
example of how industries can cross-pollinate leadership talent successfully.
It does support the notion that industry-specific expertise is not always a
definitive requirement for senior leadership roles, including in the assessment
department. Here are some additional points to consider in defense of my
proposal:
1. Transferable Skills: Top-school MBAs often possess transferable skills, such
as strategic thinking, analytical abilities, leadership, and problem-solving capabilities,
that can be applied across different industries. While they may lack specific
property assessment and taxation knowledge, their aptitude for learning quickly
and adapting to new environments can be valuable in driving innovation and
change within the department.
2. Fresh Perspectives: External hires, including top-school MBAs, can bring fresh
perspectives and new ways of approaching challenges that may not be limited by
traditional industry norms. Their outsider perspective can lead to creative
solutions and out-of-the-box thinking that may not have been considered by
someone deeply entrenched in the industry.
3. Disruption and Transformation: Bringing in leaders from outside the industry can introduce a
culture of disruption and transformation that can benefit organizations looking
to break away from outdated practices and embrace change, which can be
particularly valuable in a rapidly evolving landscape where innovative
solutions are needed to address shifting market dynamics.
4. Risk
and Adaptability:
It's important to acknowledge that hiring leaders without industry-specific
expertise carries risk. However, organizations willing to take that
risk often look to adapt to new challenges and remain competitive in changing
environments. The ability of top-school MBAs to adapt, learn quickly, and drive
strategic initiatives can mitigate this risk.
5. Leadership
Skillset:
Ultimately, a leader's success, whether within the industry or from a
different sector, depends on their leadership skillset, vision, and ability to
inspire and motivate teams. While industry-specific knowledge is valuable, it
can be acquired over time, especially with a strong, supportive team backing
the leader.
In light of these points, Starbucks's hiring of a CEO from a different industry underscores the
idea that fresh perspectives and leadership qualities can trump specific
industry expertise in certain situations. By leveraging the strengths and
capabilities of top-school MBAs, assessment departments can revitalize their
strategies, drive innovation, and navigate challenges effectively, especially
in the face of a rapidly changing landscape and plummeting commercial tax base.
Conclusion
In
conclusion, as large metropolitan assessment agencies face the challenges posed
by the declining commercial tax base and fluctuating property values in the
wake of the work-from-home trend, it is imperative to adopt a new approach in
selecting leadership for these crucial roles. The traditional practice of
promoting chief assessors from within or hiring from competitors no longer
suffices in the face of complex realities that demand exceptional leadership
and vision.
By
looking beyond technical assessing skills and instead prioritizing a broader
set of management and leadership qualities, such as those possessed by
top-school MBAs with backgrounds in the industry, assessment departments can
effectively navigate the shifts in vacancies and property values. Leveraging
the expertise and experience of these professionals from leading banks, real
estate brokerages, valuation firms, and management consulting can bring fresh
perspectives, strategic insight, and innovative solutions to address the
evolving landscape of property assessments.
In
embracing this disruptive proposal, large municipalities and assessing agencies
have the opportunity to not only meet the challenges of the current environment
but also to drive meaningful change and progress in the field of property
assessment. By opening up recruitment to top-school MBAs and conducting
interviews with industry leaders, we can usher in a new era of leadership
better equipped to steer assessment departments toward success in the face of
changing times.
In
the face of unprecedented challenges, the time is now to revolutionize how we
approach leadership in metropolitan assessment agencies. By embracing
top-school MBAs with industry backgrounds as potential Chief Assessors, we can
pave the way for innovation, efficiency, and effectiveness in addressing the
impact of the work-from-home trend on property values and revenue streams. This
bold step toward transformation promises a brighter future for both
agencies and the taxpayers they serve.
Sid's Bookshelf: Elevate Your Personal and Business Potential
